Best-rated hotels in Shelter Island for your unforgettable stay

Detailed descriptions, travelers’ reviews, and handpicked hotel collections will help you book your perfect accommodation.

Check-in date:
Check-out date:
0 Adults

Adults

0 Children

Children

Apply

Why book with us?

Choose from exclusive hotel collection

We offer thousands of Shelter Island hotels and accommodations from world's renowned hotel chains to unique gems of the region you won’t find anywhere else.

Enjoy seamless booking experience

Once you choose your best place to stay, take a minute to complete a quick reservation form and get an instant confirmation letter to your email address.

Benefit from flexible travel options

We provide the most flexible cancellation options, so you get your deposit back in case of a change of plans or other unforeseen circumstances.

Find a hotel

Hotels by class
4 stars 2
2 stars 1
Unrated 3
Accommodation type
Hotels 3
Holiday homes 3
Thematic Hotels
Hotels with indoor pool 3
Vacation Rentals 3
Luxury accommodations 3
Beach hotels 3
Extended Stay 3
Resorts 2
Spa hotels 2
Beachfront hotels 2
Central hotels 2
Luxury hotels 2
Travel Proud 1
Family Friendly hotels 1
Romantic hotels 1
Boutique hotels 1
Private Villas 1
Exceptional design hotels 1
All Shelter Island hotels

Hotels by location

Nearby
City Center Shelter Island 4
Landmarks
Popular attractions
New York Metropolitan area >
Shelter Island

Welcome to Shelter Island

Shelter Island awaits with its unspoiled beauty and serene landscapes, making it a tranquil destination for nature enthusiasts. Discover charming coastal villages, indulge in fresh seafood, and explore the picturesque beaches. Unwind in the peaceful ambiance and immerse yourself in the island's rich history. Embark on a memorable journey to Shelter Island and experience a true haven of tranquility.

What our users say about Shelter Island hotels

Doubletree By Hilton New York Times Square West
9.8

Exceptional

us Phil 15 October 2022
The location of this place is perfect, very close to all metro lines, and our room had a modern design with a fantastic view and an extra duvet provided.
Read more +
Show Less -
Hotel Edison Times Square
9.8

Exceptional

us Glenn 09 March 2023
In the signature king suite, you can enjoy watching TV on a flat-screen with lots of channels, control the room temperature to your liking, and keep your valuables safe in an individual safe. The bed was super comfy, making for a great night's sleep. Plus, the breakfast here was simply amazing and really delicious! 🍳
Read more +
Show Less -
Moxy Nyc Times Square
9.8

Exceptional

us Roger 14 January 2023
The hotel was stylish and located in a really cool area. the staff on the early morning shift were knowledgeable. - the location was convenient, just a 10-minute walk from R Lounge. - I loved the functional room with an amazing shower, 2 double beds, and a kettle.
Read more +
Show Less -
Hyatt Place New York City - Times Square
9.8

Exceptional

us Kyle 24 February 2023
the hotel was an amazing base for exploring New York City. the ideal location was just a couple of blocks away from the Ride. 3. There was a lovely restaurant within a short walk from the hotel venue.
Read more +
Show Less -
Millennium Hotel Broadway Times Square
9.8

Exceptional

us John 14 March 2023
A great spot for shopping with a fantastic new room featuring queen beds, a bathroom, and a view of the skyline, in a central location to explore the city.
Read more +
Show Less -
New Yorker By Lotte Hotels
9.8

Exceptional

us Paul 11 December 2022
Stayed at this hotel for 4 nights. The location was great, right on the main street. 🏙️
Read more +
Show Less -
Row Nyc At Times Square
9.8

Exceptional

us Betty 14 September 2022
Great location near Palace Theatre! The area around here is super fun, with Times Square, restaurants, and the subway all within easy reach. It's a really convenient spot to be based out of. 🎉
Read more +
Show Less -
Riu Plaza New York Times Square
9.8

Exceptional

us Katherine 13 August 2022
We had a great time.
Read more +
Show Less -
The Manhattan At Times Square
9.8

Exceptional

us Bonnie 14 April 2023
Great location right near Broadway and Times Square, can't beat that! Also, super close to everything around here. 🌟
Read more +
Show Less -
Hilton Garden Inn New York Central Park South-Midtown West
9.8

Exceptional

us Zach 03 February 2023
The setting near Central Park and Times Square was excellent. the room I booked was good-sized and well-maintained with a spectacular window view. the amenities like wine and a refrigerator were provided.
Read more +
Show Less -

Save time on your trip arrangements by booking one of our hand-picked hotels

Best 4-star hotels
Quality 2-star hotels
Experience the best value for your money by checking out our selection of 4-star Shelter Island hotels.
The Pridwin Hotel

81 Shore Road, Shelter Island, United States

Excellent
78 reviews

334 US$

min. price/night

Sunset Beach

35 Shore Road, Shelter Island, United States

596 US$

min. price/night

Discover the hidden gems of Shelter Island by booking one of its budget-friendly hotels.
Ram'S Head Inn

108 South Rams Island Drive, Shelter Island, United States

407 US$

min. price/night

Travelers’ choice

Check out the most booked accommodations to find reliable places that our users have tried and tested.
Shelter Island Retreat With Outdoor Pool! Villa

78 S Ram Island Dr, Shelter Island, United States

Excellent
1 review

Sandpoint By Rove Travel - 6Br Family Home With Pool

Brander Parkway 13, Shelter Island, United States

Haven On Glynn By Rove Travel - Coastal Luxury Villa

16 Glynn Drive, Shelter Island, United States

Thank you for your feedback

Close